In 1929 René Magritte painted a tobacco pipe, glossy as a shop-window ad, and people gave him hell for what he wrote under it. Anybody with eyes could see what it was. Years later he invited his critics to try filling it with tobacco, and none of them could, because it was oil on canvas, and the only honest thing in the room was the line of schoolroom cursive at the bottom of the frame. Ceci n’est pas une pipe.
We don’t live in the world. We live in our pictures of it, and we’ve been trying to smoke them since we came down out of the trees.
In 1633 the Church put Galileo on trial for suggesting the painting had the earth in the wrong place, and he spent the rest of his life under house arrest while the planet went on circling the sun, indifferent to the verdict. The map won the trial. The territory never showed up to testify. Every theology ever written is a portrait of the infinite, made by a finite animal with a short life and a strong opinion, then hung in a building and guarded by men in robes, and a lot of human history is people burning each other over the brushstrokes. No, your religion is not God.
Long before you met anyone, you were handed a casting call. The man who knows what you need before you say it. The woman who is beautiful at breakfast and never tired. The love you never have to work at, because if you have to work at it, it must not be the one. Then a real person shows up, with a real body and a real childhood, and you spend twenty years auditioning them for a role they never applied for and getting furious every time they flub a line nobody gave them. We call that romance. It’s an attempt to bully the territory into matching the painting. No, this is not your husband. This is not your wife.
Hand someone a photograph and they’ll point. “That’s my mother, right there on the right.” No, sir. That’s a few million dots of ink arranged to suggest the light that bounced off your mother for a two-hundred-fiftieth of a second, a long time ago. She has changed her hair since that picture. She may have changed her mind about a few things. She may be gone. The photograph doesn’t know, because a photograph never learns anything after the shutter closes, which makes it the most confident liar in your house. This is not your mother.
To every unfortunate man who ever hit send on a picture of his junk, that is not a dick. It’s a picture of what was, at one point, briefly, a dick, and no current evidence suggests it still exists. The only dick that exists is the one who sent it. Please stop.
Physicists are fighting right now over whether reality itself is a simulation. Melvin Vopson at the University of Portsmouth argues that gravity may be a sign the cosmos is running like a computer. A team led by Mir Faizal at UBC Okanagan says it has proved, with Gödel’s incompleteness theorem, that no computer could ever run it. I have no idea who’s right. What delights me is the shape of the fight, two groups of brilliant people drawing maps of the territory to argue over whether the territory is a map. Korzybski would have bought them both a drink. This is not the universe.
I spent years as a man who could read any room and hand it exactly what it wanted, and what I found in my own therapy is that the performer didn’t retire when the theology did. He just found new audiences. Your résumé, your diagnosis, your profile picture, the story you tell at parties about who you are and how you got here, all of it is paint, and the hardest portrait to catch is the one you painted from the inside. This is not you. It’s possibly a part of you, the avatar you send out into the room. You are not the avatar.
Magritte couldn’t leave his own pipe alone either. In 1966 he painted The Two Mysteries, the first painting propped on an easel, caption and all, and above it a second pipe floating in the air, bigger and darker and more convincing. There, you think, that’s the real one. Everyone who walks out of one map walks straight into the next. We become aware of being aware, maps of maps. We evolve our painting skills, we grow, but we never get out of the paint. Nobody does. These are paintings too.
Curiosity is a discipline, because nobody feels curious about a painting they already believe in, and to be a disciple of curiosity means to question everything, even the inherited.
I’m curious which things in my own life are actually maps, and how much of the territory I can really see. That’s the quest I’m on, the quest for curiosity, because I suspect it’s the only cure.
Ceci n’est pas une putain de pipe.



